This was originally published in The Athletic.

Bryan Price faced a decision Monday night.

The Reds manager’s team was locked in a five-all game with the Phillies in the eighth inning, desperately needing a win to prevent the young season from spiraling out on control before it even really begins. They’d battled back from deficits of 3-1 and 5-3, and despite being betrayed by starting pitching, defense, baserunning and clutch hitting, Price’s Reds were engaged in a game that was clearly for the taking.

In the top of the eighth, Price needed a pinch-hitter for Wandy Peralta, who’d just become the third Cincinnati reliever to turn in a solid performance, throwing an inning of scoreless ball. Jesse Winker was sent to the plate as Price wrestled with what to do when his team’s turn to bat was over.

To read more, go to The Athletic.